Comparing astrobiologists’ confidence in extraterrestrial life claims for K2-18 b and Cheyava Falls

Polling Firm
Other
Geographic Region
North America
Poll Start and End Date
2025-04-01
to:
2025-10-31
Description

This is a Paper published in Nature Astronomy and found on other platforms as well. Our link is to the Oxford University Research Archive, which is not firewalled.

Following two major 2025 announcements of possible extraterrestrial life — on exoplanet K2-18 b in April and in the Cheyava Falls rock on Mars in September — we surveyed the astrobiology community to capture the spread of expert opinion. These datasets establish baseline measures of scientific confidence in each case, revealing that astrobiologists were notably more persuaded by the Martian evidence than by that from K2-18 b.

The link to Nature Astronomy: Comparing astrobiologists’ confidence in extraterrestrial life claims for K2-18 b and Cheyava Falls | Nature Astronomy

Methodology
The study was pre-registered on 9 July 2024, using the Open Science Framework, with the title ‘The next big announcement of possible extraterrestrial life detection: planned surveys of astrobiology community opinion’; see: https://osf.io/xusv7/overview.
Poll Question 1
Scientists have probably found extraterrestrial life on exoplanet K2-18b
Poll Question 2
Scientists have probably discovered (ancient) extraterrestrial life in the Cheyava Falls rock on Mars

Other Interesting UAP Polls

Ipsos Logo

Many Americans believe in the supernatural, UFOs

one in ten Americans report that they have seen an unidentified flying object (UFO), unchanged over time. Four times as many Americans (42%) believe in UFOs. When it comes to other unexplainable phenomena, about three in ten (28%) report that, at some point, they have woken up from sleep with a sense of a strange presence in the room, and one in four (25%) have seen or believed themselves to have been in the presence of a ghost. Beyond that experience, two in five (39%) believe in ghosts.

Read More »