The San Marino Scale

Infographic describing the San Marino Scale, a 0-10 scale quantifying the risk of messaging to an extraterrestrial intelligence, including the factors increasing the risk score and potential consequences of ET contact
What it Does
An analytical framework used to assess the potential risk and hazard associated with sending intentional transmissions from Earth into space.
Description

What the Scale Describes

The scale calculates the potential risk of a transmission, assigning it an integer value from 1 to 10 (with 10 being the highest risk). The score is calculated using the formula: SMI = I + C.

  • I (Intensity): A logarithmic measure of the signal’s strength relative to the background radiation of the Sun. A weak, diffuse signal scores low, while a highly concentrated, powerful beam (such as a planetary radar) scores high.

  • C (Character): This evaluates the information content, direction, and intent of the message. A random, untargeted burst of radar scores low, while a sustained, broadband message targeting a specific star system—or a direct reply to a detected extraterrestrial signal—scores high.

The Value of the San Marino Scale

The scientific community is deeply divided over the safety of Active SETI, with some scientists arguing that shouting our location into the cosmos could attract hostile civilizations (often referred to as the “Dark Forest” theory), while others argue it is a necessary step for making contact. The primary value of the San Marino Scale is that it removes emotion from the debate. Instead of issuing blanket prohibitions or allowing reckless broadcasting, the scale provides policymakers and astronomers with an objective, mathematical basis to evaluate the safety of any proposed transmission before it is sent.

History and Comments

The scale was developed jointly by Hungarian astronomer Prof. Iván Almár (who also co-developed the Rio Scale) and American SETI researcher Prof. H. Paul Shuch.

They first introduced the concept in April 2005 during a SETI conference held in the Republic of San Marino (which is where the scale gets its name). Following peer feedback, the final version was published in the journal Acta Astronautica in 2007, and it was officially adopted by the SETI Permanent Study Group of the International Academy of Astronautics (IAA) in September 2007.